There have been many Questions Of The Day along the lines of 'If money wasn't a problem...' or 'What features would your ideal device have?'. They're great questions; I love the answers people give. We can all dream; it's healthy. But reality for most of us (Shaun excepted, of course :-) is living in the world of compromise. We have to balance many factors: price, features, looks, usability, OS etc. And always with a view to an uncertain future: if I invest in software for this device/OS, where will it be in 6, 12 or 18 months time?
It's a fascinating call - and a deeply frustrating one at times. The relative priorities of the different buying factors are rarely set in stone; price might be a constraint now but maybe not so much next year - or it may be more so next year. Usability is relative - what seems to adequately meet our needs now, in comparison with other available devices, can seem archaic all-too-soon, blown out of the water by an Android perhaps.
Here's some flesh on the bones of this dilemma. I'm currently using a Nokia 6120, my first Symbian device. I really love the small form factor - but I'm frustrated by the screen size. It didn't cost much - but it's fiddly to use. The software it comes with, and which I've added, is mostly adequate - but there are programs I have invested in that just aren't available for symbian devices.
What would my ideal device be? I'd love to try the iPhone 3G - the only box it wouldn't currently tick is that some of my favourite software isn't ported to it (although I've no doubt it will be). But try it I can't - locked into a non-o2 contract for another 13 months and with insufficient funds to simply bite the bullet and tear-up the contract. So in the land of compromise, other solutions must prevail.
And I might just have found that solution. A price reduction on the MWg Atom Life (down to £150) makes it attainable. Its large screen makes it attractive. The option to use already-owned software makes it advantageous. Its relative bulk makes it awkward.
Depeche Mode once urged us to 'get the balance right'. That's part of the skill of living in a world of compromise. Maybe this device, at this time, for these reasons, will be a right balance - for my needs and situation. It certainly seems like it.
Or maybe I'd be better-off with a Nokia 6120/iPod Touch combo....? Richard M.